Groups don't expand to contain notes #13

New Issue

2025-07-14T19:50:01Z

HEL commented

2025-07-14 19:50:01 +00:00

Groups containing notes don't take their size into account, often leading to overflow, as shown below

Example

#diagram({
  _grp("Group", {
    _seq("a", "b", comment: [Sequence])
    _note("left")[Note]
  })
  _grp("Group", {
    _seq("b", "a", comment: [Sequence])
    _note("right")[Note]
  })
  _grp("Group", {
    _seq("a", "b", comment: [Sequence], start-tip: ">")
    _note("over", pos: ("a", "b"), lorem(5))
  })
})

Result

Groups containing notes don't take their size into account, often leading to overflow, as shown below ## Example ```typ #diagram({ _grp("Group", { _seq("a", "b", comment: [Sequence]) _note("left")[Note] }) _grp("Group", { _seq("b", "a", comment: [Sequence]) _note("right")[Note] }) _grp("Group", { _seq("a", "b", comment: [Sequence], start-tip: ">") _note("over", pos: ("a", "b"), lorem(5)) }) }) ``` ## Result ![group_notes.png](/attachments/69170a18-34c1-4e9b-a765-f4e96aafe0e2)

group_notes.png

61 KiB

HEL added this to the 0.3.0 milestone 2025-07-14 19:50:01 +00:00

HEL added the bug label 2025-07-14 19:50:01 +00:00

HEL commented

2025-07-16 14:18:47 +00:00

This also affects neighboring participants
Note widths are not taken into account when computing column widths

PlantUML's behavior lets note overlap neighboring participants. Chronos could let user decide whether notes should behave as shown below or reserve space to avoid overlaps

#diagram({
  _par("a")
  _par("b")
  _par("c")
  _seq("b", "c")
  _note("left")[Note]
})

~This also affects neighboring participants Note widths are not taken into account when computing column widths~ PlantUML's behavior lets note overlap neighboring participants. Chronos could let user decide whether notes should behave as shown below or reserve space to avoid overlaps ```typst #diagram({ _par("a") _par("b") _par("c") _seq("b", "c") _note("left")[Note] }) ``` ![issue13.png](/attachments/601c95f3-b784-4ede-869e-393d441af92b)

issue13.png

16 KiB

HEL referenced a pull request that will close this issue

2025-07-16 16:51:09 +00:00

Fix notes width not taken into account #16

HEL closed this issue

2025-07-16 16:53:09 +00:00

Sign in to join this conversation.